A common task for a transistor is switching a device on and off. There are two configurations for a transistor switch: low side and high side. The location of the transistor determines the type of circuit and its name. Either transistor configuration can use a BJT or MOSFET.
In this post, I draw the configuration for both transistor types, talk about which requires a driver, and explain why you would use either. If you are new to transistors, check out the resource links at the bottom. I have a couple of videos I made and some from element14’s The Learning Circuit which do a great job introducing transistors.
Low-side transistor configuration
When the transistor is connected to ground, that means the load is between +V and the transistor. Since the transistor is switching the path to ground or is sitting on the low side of the load, it is called a low side switch.
Typically these use an NPN BJT or an N-Channel MOSFET.
For an NPN BJT, the emitter connects to ground, and the collector attaches to the negative side of the load. As a switch, the BJT operates in saturation mode. Saturation means there is enough base current to turn on the transistor fully.
For an N-Channel MOSFET, the source connects to ground, and the drain connects to the negative side of the load. While you can use a JFET for this circuit, an enhancement mode MOSFET works better.
High-side transistor switch
The opposite of the low side switch is the high side switch. This transistor connects between +V and the load. Because of how transistors work, these can be a little more difficult to use in an Arduino or Raspberry Pi circuit.
Typically these use a PNP BJT or P-Channel MOSFET.
For a PNP BJT, the emitter connects to the voltage source, while the collector connects to the load’s positive side. Looking at the schematic drawing for an NPN and PNP, the PNP might look like it is upside down. Just like the NPN, the PNP BJT needs to be operating in the saturation region to turn on the transistor fully.
For a P-Channel MOSFET, the source connects to the voltage source, and the drain connects to the load’s positive side. Like with the low-side, you probably want to use an enhancement mode MOSFET. Keep in mind that you may never find a depletion mode P-Channel. They only exist in textbooks and as data entry errors.
When using a P-type transistor on a load voltage that is the same voltage level as the signal driving the transistor, the circuit above works fine. Well, the logic is inverted, but other than that, is fine. For a detailed explanation, check out this post I wrote on P-Channel MOSFET Tutorial with only Positive Voltages.
When the load voltage is HIGHER than the signal voltage, you need a driver. Next, let’s see how a driver gets used with low-side and high-side transistor switches.
Transistor driving another transistor
A driver transistor circuit is one that controls another transistor. This circuit is not the same as a BJT Darlington pair, which is a high gain BJT. Instead, a transistor driver is used when the driving signal’s voltage (or current) is not compatible with the load transistor. Below are two cases where you might need to use a transistor driver. These are, by no means, the only ones. So if you know of a case, or suspect you need one, leave a comment with it.
High current MOSFETs have a substantial Vgs threshold. While 5 volts from an Arduino GPIO pin might be enough to turn on the transistor, it isn’t enough to drive it into saturation. Until the FET is saturated, its Rds-ON can be relatively high, limiting the maximum current it can handle.
It is very common to use an NPN driver with a PNP BJT or P-Channel MOSFET, when the load voltage is higher than the signal voltage. Without a driver, the transistor may never turn-off. The driver, effectively, boosts the driving voltage high enough to unbias the Vbe or Vgs junction of the transistor. My tutorial on PWM a PC fan is an example of an Arduino driving a 12 volt fan with a PNP.
Why even bother with high-side transistors?
For both BJT and MOSFET transistors, their P-Type generally have more resistance (or lower current capability) than their N-type counterparts. For that reason, some might conclude you should always use an N-type in a low-side configuration.
However, step back and think for a second what the two different circuit types are doing. The low-side switch is switching ground while the high-side switch is connecting the voltage supply. Generally in a circuit, you want to keep the ground connected and switch the power. One reason is that even when the transistor is fully turned on, there is still a small voltage drop across it. That voltage drop means the ground is not 0 volts for that device. For something simple like an LED, it does not matter which you switch. However, an active device like a Microcontroller needs its ground to be ground! So when you have a load that requires ground, you NEED to use a high-side switch.
As a quick rule of thumb, if you are turning a device on and off, a low-side switch is a simple solution. However, if you are delivering power to an entire circuit or a voltage sensitive device, then you want to use a high-side switch.
By the way, there are off-the-shelf components called a “load switch.” These are ICs that have a P-Channel MOSFET as the switching transistor with a built-in driver for that P-Channel. There is no external driver needed for this type of components.
Transistor Basics Links (for Reference)
- The Learning Circuit, How Transistors Work. Karen explains from the ground-up how bipolar junction transistors (BJTs) operate. There are many transistor physics explanations on the web, but Karen’s is the clearest one I have come across.
- The Learning Circuit, BJT Feedback. In this TLC episode, I joined Karen and addressed some misconceptions from the community (and I suspect others) on the video linked above.
- AddOhms, BJTs. The video I made about BJTs. I don’t get into how the electrons work, but instead, show how to use one in a circuit.
- AddOhms, MOSFETs. Part two of my transistor videos. In this episode, I explain how to use MOSFETs. (This video is the most popular on my YouTube channel with, literally, millions of views.)
Question: What are other popular transistor configurations you have used in your circuits? You can leave a comment by clicking here.